Marauder parallels

lrcjestes lrcjestes at msn.com
Mon Nov 6 03:09:43 UTC 2000


No: HPFGUIDX 5189

From: <Ellimist15 at aol.com>


> Quin said:
> I think that the paralleled couples are Harry-James, Hermione-Sirius,
> Ron-Pettigrew, and Neville-Lupin
>
> Really? I thought of them as Harry-James, Hermione-Lupin, and Ron-Sirius.

I'm with you Ellie.  I meant to reply to this when it was first posted...but
forgot after going through another 35 posts...

I don't see a Hermione - Sirius parrallel in the least...Hermione - Lupin
absolutely as Ellie has so eloquently posted.  They are the academics.

Ron - Sirius for their tempers and spirit and best friend capacity to
James - Harry.

Pettigrew is such a wormy guy, I would think Neville if anyone, although
that would be an insult to Neville and as we found out more about Neville in
GoF..it might be unbelievable as well.

Can't muster the intellectual energy to defend these parallels at the
moment...maybe tomorrow.

carole







More information about the HPforGrownups archive