Continuity Question

Kelley SKTHOMPSON_1 at msn.com
Sun Oct 22 21:57:20 UTC 2000


No: HPFGUIDX 4408

--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, HarryPotterJrs at a... wrote:
> Forgive me if this has been discussed.  I brought it up before, but 
either no 
> one commented, or I missed it.
> 
> In the end of GoF, Voldemorts wand extracted the following people:  
Diggory, 
> old man, Bertha Jorkins, the dad, then the mom.  But the wand is 
supposed to 
> extract the 'spirits' of who Voldemort killed, backwords.  This 
would mean he 
> killed his mom first, then went after the dad.  But didn't he kill 
the dad 
> first, go after Harry, and his mom got in the middle, so he had to 
kill her 
> to get to Harry?  Maybe I have this all wrong, but its bugging me.  
> 
> I read the first 3 books to the family from the library, and have 
them on 
> order, thus we only own the last book right now, so I can't check 
out all the 
> facts.  Thanks for the help!
> ~shahara in WI

Shahara--

Please don't think you're being ignored; this topic was brought up 
just days after the release of GoF, and has been discussed ad 
infinitum by the group.  You can find some discussion of it on this 
site by searching for "Priori Incantatem."  This will not bring up 
all the discussion, by any means, but it is some.  It was also 
discussed when the group was still on yahoo, but you can find those 
posts in the HPfG's archive site.  There is a darling group of folks 
diligently working on creating a list of FAQs for this group.  A 
daunting task, they've been scouring ~all~ the posts to create 
concise answers and info based on the many recurring threads of 
discussion.  As you might imagine, this is quite time-consuming, so 
just hang in there, you'll soon be able to get the info.  In the 
meantime, you may want to check out Steve's Lexicon site; lots of 
great info there.  Here's the URL:  
http://www.i2k.com/~svderark/lexicon/ 

Kelley





More information about the HPforGrownups archive