Weasley's and that age gap.
Kelley
SKTHOMPSON_1 at msn.com
Thu Sep 21 04:28:57 UTC 2000
No: HPFGUIDX 1822
--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, "Simon Branford"
> A couple of corrections are needed in here. In PS (Ch13) it is said
that it
> is seven years since Gryffindor have won the House Cup. It is in
PoA that it
> is said that it is seven years since they have won the Quidditch
Cup (PoA
> Chs12 & 15).
> Simon (who needs to get back to writing these FAQ's)
Simon, and anyone else who's interested--
When you said it was seven years since Gryff won the House Cup in SS,
I was thinking Quid Cup too. So, I went back through SS to check,
and I can't find Quid Cup mentioned anywhere. When McG confronts
Harry, Herm, and Neville when they get caught coming from the tower
to give Norbert to Charlie's friends (well, Harry and Herm were in
the tower, Nev was out of bed), McG takes fifty points apiece from
Gryff to punish them. (Along with the Forbidden Forest.) Harry's
upset because this meant they lost the lead for the HOUSE Cup, the
lead they'd gotten when Harry won the last Quid match. If there's a
Quid Cup as well as a House Cup, winning a Quid match wouldn't affect
their chances for the House cup would it? The Quid Cup isn't
mentioned until CoS, Ch. 7 "Mudbloods and Murmurs", p. 108 Am
version. Really, go back through SS, Quid Cup is never mentioned.
Do you think JKR realized how old it would make Bill and Charlie if
it had been seven years before SS that they'd gotten out of school?
Then decided to create and add in the Quid cup so she could say it'd
been seven years (by PoA) since they'd won the Quid Cup, seven years
since Charlie was there? Hope this wasn't too confusing...
Kelley
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive