Hermione in US/UK
Amy Z
aiz24 at hotmail.com
Sun Apr 8 10:49:03 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 16063
Ahhhhh . . . I have just returned from Canada, Land of the UK
Editions, and am finally, joyfully the owner of my very own Harry
Potter books! I will resist buying a full set of the US edition, but
thanks to the library I can now indulge in one of my favorite
obsessions: finding differences between the editions. Some, like the
fact that Harry refers to his "mum," not his "mom," in PS, just
confirm my view that Arthur Levine is being a disingenuous jerk when
he says they only translated the expressions that would cause
confusion. I accuse him of trying to Americanize Harry. They seem to
have stopped making that particular change since JKR made it big.
But I'm particularly intrigued by the more substantial changes.
Here's one:
UK PoA, p. 272:
"Er--Mr. Black--Sirius?" said Hermione timidly.
Black jumped at being addressed like this and stared at Hermione as
though being spoken to politely was something he'd long forgotten.
US PoA, p. 370:
"Er--Mr. Black--Sirius?" said Hermione.
Black jumped at being addressed like this and stared at Hermione as
though he had never seen anything quite like her.
I really like the change. The UK version seems a bit obvious to me.
The US version also de-timidifies Hermione, which leads me to another
passage that I'm 99% sure doesn't exist in the US edition (darn . . .
maybe I do need a set of those . . . no! bad! ::bangs head against
wall::):
'I think we'll be able to pull the door open,' said Ron, peering
over [Fluffy's] back. 'Want to go first, Hermione?'
'No, I don't!'
'All right.' Ron gritted his teeth and stepped carefully over the
dog's legs. He bent and pulled the ring of the trapdoor . . . etc.
(PS p. 200)
Could someone with a US edition confirm that this isn't in it? I
could swear I've never read that before.
Amy Z
------------------------------------
"Yeah, Dumbledore's barking, all
right," said Ron proudly.
-HP and the Philosopher's Stone
------------------------------------
new, corrected sig (formerly said "off his rocker")
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive