[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape and Lucius Malfoy

[Dinah]

No: HPFGUIDX 17326

Following up on Lea's comments and thoughts:
>>The following theory can only be reasonable if we assume that the "one who
>> has left us forever" comment of Voldemort wasn't directed at the absent
>> Snape.
>At who else?

I have no idea. But if he knows all discussion of Snape's further spying
activities seem quite futile - and it seems that he *did* spy at the end of
GoF. (Just what was his former postition? I sooo want to know to what he
returned.)

>>Which raises the problem that Snape *was* at the DE meeting - which
>> means he would have known that Lucius was there *and* saw everything that
>> happened to Harry.
>Ah, if he was, Ill immediately renounce everything Ive ever said in
>defence of him. The very idea he was there gives me the shivers!!!
>Ive never even considered the possibility. Has anyone else?

I though about that - and isn't it a miracle that Harry managed to escape at
the end? He doesn't really notice what's going on behind him, he just shoots
random curses over his back. It is highly unlikely that they hit many DE
since they weren't aimed at all. So - had he help from the inside? Snape?
Things were progressing so fast that if he was there he didn't really have a
chance to step in earlier, maybe was waiting for the right moment. What if
Voldemort risen to full power might be easier to kill/destroy than in the
half human
state he was in before? Returned power = returned humanity?

> My "theorie" (which is based on opinion and my imagination, since there
are> little facts given) is that Lucius doesn't know that Severus spied for>
Dumbledore.
>>That doesnt quite correspond with the question above, does it?

No, it doesn't. But many things don't sum up here and we're probably in for
some harsh surprises.

D**






_________________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com