Pondering the details of Goblet (contents vary)

[lamppost42 at hotmail.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 23460

> Was he a member?  I always got the impression he was there as an 
> observer / advisor / witness.

That's I read it, too. We already know that the committee allowed the 
Dementors against Dumbledore's protestations, so it wouldn't be the 
first time he disagreed with them.

> Yet Pomfrey is a highly respected member of Dumbledore's handpicked 
>staff. So why is she regarded as so much less trustworthy than some of >the others? 

I can just hear Mrs. Weasley and Madame Pomfrey tsking the dangerous 
tasks in unison. So far, their characters have been portrayed very 
similarly in how they react to finding the students in danger. However, 
I feel that including Mrs. Weasley in the conversation indicates that 
there is quite a bit more to her than the overprotective disciplinarian 
we've seen so far.

> (Must be chilly without undergarments either.)

And flying up in the air without undergarments with all those Death 
Eaters circling below? How can you possibly live in fear of someone 
whose skinny bottom you've seen? :D

Mun42