"True" Prediction. (Was: Time Of Trelawney's First)

[banjoken at optonline.net]

No: HPFGUIDX 24092

> While we're on the subject - is there anyone else who finds 
> Dumbledore's criticising of her abilities odd? She makes several 
> correct predictions in canon - for example, she was predicting 
>Sirius for practically all of Book 3.

I think this is just luck on her part. Trelawney's specialty is 
seeing death omens, so I think it's just a strange coincidence that 
Sirius is on the loose as a big black dog. Remember that McGonagall 
said Trelawney had predicted the death of a student every year since 
she arrived.

Ken