[HPforGrownups] Student Teacher - Werewolf Cubs - True Prediction

[Dave Hardenbrook]

No: HPFGUIDX 24116

On 12 Aug 2001, at 20:27, Rita Winston wrote:

> Why can't she ... accept a position
> as the new, reform-minded Headmistress of Durmstrang...

I like this. :)

> Altho, SO MANY people expect Neville
> to become the Herbology teacher, I don't know that it would be as big
> a surprise as JKR hints.

I'm counting on his winding up as the Potions master! 

> But the point we're arguing over is whether the Prediction had ALREADY
> come true AT THE TIME that Dumbledore identified it as Trelawney's
> second true prediction. Dumbledore's statement was near the end of PoA
> and the BFB event was in GoF, therefore had not happened YET when
> Dumbledore spoke.
> 
> SO the FIRST true prediction might not have come true yet by GoF!

What I want to know is, why is V worried (if indeed he is) about the 
prediction of someone who never made a true prediction prior to 
that?  What does he know about her that we don't??


                 -- Dave