Potters

swman19 at yahoo.com swman19 at yahoo.com
Mon Dec 3 02:42:18 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 30606

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., CB <eleri at a...> wrote:
> At 09:32 PM 12/1/01 +0000, you wrote:
> >Well, he didn't have only a year, remember, in the first chapter,
> >Harry was only a year old.  By the time Dumbledore tells Harry he
> >lived because of Lily's love, Harry was 12.  I guess by then, he 
had
> >it figured out!

It also could be that Dumbledore wasn't quite sure that Harry did 
have such a protection on him in the first place.  I bet that once he 
rushed into the chamber where the Sorcerer's Stone was being held and 
saw what happened to Quirell and Harry's own recount that Dumbledore 
finally figured it out and knew why Voldemort couldn't kill Harry 
when he was a baby.

I also agree on the fact that if Dumbledore did know ahead of time, 
he didn't tell Harry since he didn't want Harry to go around 
like, "Hey, don't worry about Voldemort.  He can't touch me!"

Thanks

Swman19






More information about the HPforGrownups archive