[HPforGrownups] Dead Narrative Sources in lit

Lucy Austin lucy at luphen.co.uk
Tue Dec 4 21:47:42 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 30765

 
> > But the stories are all told from Harrys point of view, if he died 
> do 
> > you think it would be strange to have the events afterwards from 
> > anothers pov? I know that wouldn't be a good enough reason for JKR 
> to 
> > change who is going to die but we can all hope!
> 
> 
> GF changed that by having the first chapter told from Frank Bryce's 
> POV.  Now that the seed has been sown...
> 
> Joshua Dyal

>HP woudn't be the first story to use this sort of narrative twist anyway. The most prominent recent example would of course be AMERICAN BEAUTY (which actually breaks *several* narrative rules to lovely effect), but a couple of others would be LOLITA (Humbert has died by the time the narrative framework starts) and HAMLET.

And as you can become a ghost, the last couple of paragraphs could still be from Harry's POV! I would hate him to die, but I have to admit I can quite easily see him sacrifcing himself to kill V and save the world etc.

Lucy, who really hopes no-one like HRH, Hagrid, Sirius or Remus die, but wouldn't mind Dobby dying!


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPforGrownups archive