imperius curse
christine breen
kokobreen at juno.com
Tue Dec 11 06:04:14 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 31263
<<It is important to examine what the text REALLY says.>>
Sorry I didn't quote the exact passage out of the book, I thought I made
that clear by not putting my text in quotes. Harry has the imperius
curse put on him by Voldemort and then the book says it was for the third
time blah blah (not using exact quote). This implies a third experience
with this curse. When Moody used it on Harry, he did it several times.
So the 'third time' is not correct if all the imperius curses Moody put
on Harry were counted. So Moody would probably only count as one time.
Voldemort was another time. If it really is being implied that Harry was
under the imperius curse another time than those two mentioned, it leads
to some intriguing possibilities. Someone close to him, using the famous
Harry Potter (who would never go to Voldemort's side) to spread
disinformation.
Christine
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive