Parallels between the Weasleys and King Arthur's family?
mongo62aa
william.truderung at sympatico.ca
Sat Dec 15 01:55:27 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 31603
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "frodoyoda_2000" <frodoyoda at a...> wrote:
> Actually, in many of the Arthurian tales(definitely in the Mists of
> Avalon, maybe in The Once and Future King, and others), Gareth is
not
> the youngest, Mordred is. This would align Ron with him, and he was
> the one who betrayed Arthur. Gareth was the second youngest
brother,
> which would make him either Fred or George. Gareth was killed by
> Lancelot in a fit of passion as he saved Guinevere from being
> exectued for her betrayal of Arthur.
> As I refuse to see Ron as a traitor, and really can't see Harry
> killing either of the twins to save Ginny, I think that these
> paralells
> are shady at best...
>
> retreating back into lurkdom,
> Molly
You make some good points here.
The exact relationships between characters in the Arthurian cycle
vary quite a bit, depending upon the particular version of the story
being told. Most of the modern retellings of the story do make
Mordred the youngest, but he is actually only a half-brother of the
other four, with Gareth being the youngest full brother. JKR has
apparently stated that Harry WILL be betrayed by someone, but the
person may not be an exact counterpart of Mordred.
I also agree that JKR used SOME plot elements from the Arthurian
stories, and not the entire cycle. At least I hope so ... There is
simply too much betrayal and fratricide in the original to be
enjoyable today.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive