Who will be prefect and other stuff
star_ling at wiccanet.every1.net
star_ling at wiccanet.every1.net
Thu Feb 8 23:19:03 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 11910
yes I know that this discussion was a days ago but oh well, I found
it interesting on how much people were concentrating on the grades
for who will become prefect. I think of it as who would be a good
role model and would be a good leader. Yes good grades would be a
factor but I in no way feel that is the big factor. I think that the
teachers will look at the characters for role-model material. I
think that Hermione will be a prefect because she has good grades,
trtys to keep others in line, is helpful, etc. Yes she tends to be
abit bossy but she's just trying(forecfully trying) to push others to
reach their potential and stay out of getting in trouble. I aslo
think that Harry will be made a prefect b/c he's known for being
against the dark arts which is something that the school would want
to promote. Yes he tends to break some rules accompained by Hermione
and Ron but his breaking the rules tends to save the world so I think
that that will be looked over. I've also been surprised that many
people only think that there is one prefect per house per year, I
think with the 800-1000 students that there would be more then that.
I figure that at least there is one boy and one girl per year per(5
th year and up) house and then two of them are chosen to be head boy
and girl. This brings my to something else, why would it be a
problem to have both head boy and head girl be in the same house, if
they're the best choice then they should be chosen.
As to Lily and James and co. and their houses, I think that they were
all in Gryfindor, J.K. has said that Lily was in Gryfindor and I'm
almost positve that somewhere it mentioned ONE of the MWPP gang being
in Gryfindor, therefore they all had to be b/c MWPP were all room
mates. I guess I'm just blown aways that other people didn't
persieve it that way and will have to re-read the books(for like the
fourth time, eighth if you count listening to the books on tape)
looking for evidence of some sort.
Back to the prefect thing, if there are more students allowed to be
prefects then it would be neat if Ron was chosen too and not left out
but I don't see him being chosen over Harry, he breaks just as many
rules and (no Ron loves take offense) I see Harry being the better
role model, less mentally immature and all that.
One more thing, does anyone think that it's kinda unfair that Harry
and ROn got an award in CoS but Hermione didn't, she might not have
been down in the chamber but if it wasn't for the information she
found that Harry found in her hand, Harry wouldn't have been able to
save the day. Well, I think it's unfair but then maybe that's just
me and my love for Hermione.
~Star~
off to go do that five odd hours of homework she let pile up.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive