Loss of power theory (was Harry's Special Powers)

Kimberly moongirlk at yahoo.com
Thu Jan 25 23:58:37 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 10700

I said:

> > Really digging this thread - thanks for the debate, Keith!
> > Kimberly
> 
--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, "Keith Fraser" <keith.fraser at s...> 
wrote:
> It's made me feel like a bit of an idiot for having a super-Harry in 
> my fanfic when there are so many sound arguments against that 
theory, 
> but you're welcome. I now subscribe to the Lord-of-the-rings-style-
> little-people-defeat-overconfident-Dark-Lord school of thought: JKR 
> will quite likely make Harry's victory a triumph of courage and 
> ingenuity (and probably luck) over evil.
> 

Keith,

I didn't realize you had a fanfic really (I'm ficless until after 
book 7) - I didn't mean to bum you out or anything!  I do think there 
are still holes in my theory - there's definitely room for the 
possibility of a SuperHarry, it's just I didn't like the idea myself, 
so I set out to find an explanation that suited me. 
I have really enjoyed debating it, as it's given me a chance to flesh 
out my thoughts.  Hopefully someone will find some more holes to poke 
in it, or we can find another one to toss around.  I would be thrilled 
if it ended up being even remotely right, but I know there are still 
plenty of things that aren't explained.

Happy Thursday!
kimberly





More information about the HPforGrownups archive