Why did Mrs. Weasley say that?

dfrankiswork at netscape.net dfrankiswork at netscape.net
Fri Jul 13 16:25:53 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 22498

prefectmarcus wrote:
> (4) How come the Marauder's Map didn't show two Harrys and two 
> Hermiones just before the Shrieking Shack in HP3?

Last time this came up I checked it out.  It's clear from Lupin's 
discovery of Peter that Hagrid's hut is off the edge of the map.  So 
is the Shrieking Shack (Hogsmeade).  On the two occasions when Lupin 
and Snape looked at the map, therefore, only one of each would be 
visible. Nobody else looked. (I like the idea that Dumbledore went 
into Lupin's office, saw two of each, and realised he had to tell 
them to use the time turner, but it can't be: in GOF he didn't know 
about the map.)

> (5) How come the Marauder's Map never showed Peter Pettigrew to the 
> Weasley twins or Harry before that fateful night?

various theories have been put forward.  Mine is that F&G saw PP many 
times, and either couldn't work it out or thought of it as 
Scabbers' 'real name'.  After all, the map shows Mrs Norris (what 
does that say about her?).  They were in no position to inquire, as 
they weren't supposed to have the map.

David





More information about the HPforGrownups archive