L.O.O.N., Impediment Jinx/Curse
Sam Brown
find_sam at hotmail.com
Thu Jul 26 05:25:02 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 23003
John Walton (or possibly Anal P. Lardbottom) wrote:
> We at L.O.O.N. have noted with interest your application for
membership, and, following your recent post to the Wonderful
Wizarding Web, the Board-In-General of L.O.O.N. (B-I-G L.O.O.N) is
delighted to pronounce you an Official Credentialed Member of the
League of Overly Obsessed Nitpickers.
Hurray! <g> (Mental note: Never use word 'hurray' in public again
unless have Memory charms handy)
John also wrote:
> L.O.O.N. would remind Mr Brown that death is irreversible.
Yes I know. I was just being pedantic <g>
Now to point of my post:
Joel wrote:
> The Impediment Curse is a Curse, not a Jinx. Here's the actual
quote from GoF: (snip quotes which contain the use of the
term 'Impediment Curse')
Actually, in my copy of GoF, it's 'Impediment Jinx', not 'Impediment
Curse', in all of the examples you've given. I think this is an
inconsistency in editions rather than an error on my behalf, although
I can't think why they'd change it from 'jinx' to 'curse'. Perhaps
someone at Scholastic realised there was an inconsistency in jinxes
between PS/SS and GoF and altered the books accordingly.
In any case, Hermione 'manage[s] to shatter [the Shield Charm] with a
well placed Jelly Legs Jinx', and you couldn't exactly describe words
as being 'well placed', at least not in terms of performing a magical
spell.
Sam, an Official Credentialed Member of the League of Overly Obsessed
Nitpickers (at last!)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive