Charlie and Bill Weasley(was Time line Question)

[Steve Vander Ark]

No: HPFGUIDX 23360

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., miscellanies at y... wrote:

> mean it isn't there, but ... I notice that Bill doesn't make it onto
> the lexicon time line at all which does make me wonder.

Bill isn't on the timeline because there is no evidence whatsoever to 
go on which would allow me to place him there. Charlie, yes, since I 
subscribe to the notion that his last year was the last year 
Gryffindor won the Q-Cup and therefore the House Cup. It's the 
simplest explanation. I know, I know, that point can be argued ad 
infinitum, but that's what I went with. By the same token, none of 
the Snape/James/Lupin crowd was on the timeline either until earlier 
this year when JKR revealed Snapes age. If she'd just do that now 
with Bill and Charlie (and tell us which year Hermione was born in 
too, while she's at it) we'd be all set.

I am working on a letter to JKR. I need to ask her the status of the 
new trading cards (how much input did she give and should those 
spells and facts be considered canon). Anyone want to suggest any 
other good questions to ask? No, I won't ask about the gleam or who 
falls in love with who or any of those kinds of things. But factual 
details that don't give anything away, sure. So what shall I ask her?

BTW, according to the trading cards, Flitwick's first name is Filius. 
So do I put that in the Lexicon? I'm unsure...

Steve Vander Ark
The Harry Potter Lexicon
http://www.i2k.com/~svderark/lexicon