Photos, new members, Sirius/Lupin. Scar

[purplefanta at yahoo.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 21087

Danette Schardt-Cordova <captain_debrowe at y...> wrote:

> Later in the book Colin does show Harry a picture he
> has taken(again I don't have my book handy can someone
> find the quote please?) and it says s8omething to the
> effect of "Lockheart was pulling on what looked like
> Harry's arm since the rest of him refused to enter the
> picture--eventually the picture Lockheart gave up and
> collapsed panting against the little white frame" or
> something to that effect.  So yes he did manage to get
> the picture to move (Even if the picture Harry didn't
> want to be in it) :D
> 

1) Here is my question... if a magical person (witch, wizard, etc.) 
take a picture of a muggle and a non muggle, will they both move in 
the photo?  Will neither move?  Can a muggle see the people moving in 
the photos?

2)  Ok, I have a small bone to pick, and I know that I am going to 
get reamed for saying this.  BUT, as the membership increases, there 
are many who ask questions that have been talked about previously.  
As a new member, I am sure i have done the same.  But IMHO, with all 
the new people, I am sure that there are lots of new ideas on old 
topics.  i don't think it is possible to exist as a discussion group 
and not bring up topics time and time again.  When I have a question, 
I want to know what this group thinks now... not what they decided a 
few months ago.  Perhaps, I have no right to make this request, but 
please don't yell "check the archives" everytime us newbies have 
question...  it makes me long for a Cheering Charm...

3)  I agree that Sirius made a mistake when he was 16, but I don't 
think he honestly still thinks he was justified in making that 
decision.  When he made the comment at the end of PoA, Snape had just 
nearly given him to the dementors AND caused the loss of Wormtail to 
V.  Snape had lost his cool completely, and Sirius was reacting to 
that situation.  Lupin, OTOH, has come across completely as a warm, 
fun, and couragous man.  I would have to say he is my fave charcter 
(after Hagrid)

4)  I am curious as to what format everyone thinks the last three 
books to have.  My guess is that Book 7 will be almost completely 
explanation.  I almost wonder if whether the main climax might happen 
at the end of 6/ early 7.  Then someone (Dumbledore if he is still 
alive) explains to Harry all that has happend. Or, Harry explains 
everything to someone else.  Explanation proceeds on, ending with the 
night James and Lily died.  Last sentance?  "And THAT is how you got 
your scar."

Just My thoughts, please don't hurt me....

Melissa
Can't Spell... Admit that freely