Use of names
Rosmerta
tmayor at mediaone.net
Mon May 14 17:27:34 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 18722
Amy Z wrote:
> -McGonagall actually refers to most male students by their last
names...[but] like Binns and some other professors, even Snape,
> she is more likely to refer to girls as "Miss" whomever.
I always assumed this was a function of the English Boarding School
system. Any attendees/former attendees who can verify? (Or maybe I'm
just thinking of English boarding schools in Merchant-Ivory-ish
movies).
Amy again: "Lupin calls Snape by his first name but Snape calls him
by his last > name. I'm not sure what to conclude from this. Is one
of them being > rude, and if so, which?"
I think it's Snape being rude. He and Lupin are colleagues and equals
(tho' obviously not in his mind). For Snape to refer to Lupin by his
last name--the way he refers to his male students--is a put-down.
And finally, re: Snape calling Dumbledore "headmaster," Lupin *does*
do it, once. Dumbledore tells him his carriage is waiting and he
says, "Thank you, headmaster." IIRC, those're the last words Lupin
speaks to Dumbledore. They have their awkward shake-over-the-grindlow-
tank and he's gone. Very moving.
~Rosmerta
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive