Sorting Hat and Gryffindor Weasleys
annieclaire12 at yahoo.com
annieclaire12 at yahoo.com
Fri Nov 2 08:19:49 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 28641
The sorting hat has fascinated me from the start. In PS it seemed so
arbitrary, even when viewing it from Harry's POV. Through the
archives I read some excellent posts which have provided me with
added depth to the sorting process. But I have a couple of questions
about the sorting hat with regards to the Weasleys.
With reference to sorting hat process, in post 23442 dfrankiswork@
wrote:
>characteristics (I am brave), aspirations (I want to be brave),
>priorities (I think bravery is the most important thing), morality
>(bravery is good) and choice (I want to be with the brave)
Also regarding the sorting process, in post 23468 caliburncy@ wrote:
>I believe (with no evidence from canon) that the Sorting Hat makes
>it decisions based largely on another option: potential for growth
Both of these terrific posts helped to clarify for me the sorting
process as it stands now, pending any further illumination from JKR.
Based on what I've gleaned from these examples, the hat considers a
number of factors (aspirations, personal choice, potential for
growth) inherent within each student. Although the factors are
unique to that individual, as a whole they predispose them to a
particular house. Neville and Hermione may have different traits and
varied priorities, yet in the aggregate they each reflect the
Gryffindor spirit.
My question is with the sorting process and the Weasley family. To me
it seems a little odd that every member of a large family such as the
Weasleys would each be a Gryffindor. Surely in a family of nine
there'd be some sibling that is in total opposite to another in terms
of house predispositon. So in addition to the above factors, does
the sorting house also consider family history? Like a 'legacy'.
While JKR did separate the Patil twins, she also kept Draco a
Slytherin.
So I guess my question is, how much of a factor do you think family
history is to the sorting process?
Annie-Claire (whose only other example of a 'legacy' is Flounder in
Animal House)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive