Lupin's Patronus

[laoisecronin at yahoo.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 28775

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Starling" <starling823 at y...> wrote:
> I just had a quick thought --
> Lupin's Patronus is "formless silver stuff" -- could it perhaps be 
clouds?
> After all, clouds would hide the moon from his view.  While I'm not 
trying
> to make a statement as to the actual effect of clouds on his 
transformation,
> I do think it's possible that he could see clouds as a bit of 
protection --
> visually, if nothing else.
> 
> just my 2 knuts, as I call friends to find out when we're going to 
see
> Monsters Inc. tonight to see the last movie trailer :)
> 
> Abbie, who is amused that she snuck a movie reference in.  ::waves 
cheerily
> to Neil in his usherette uniform::
> starling823 at y...
 Sorry i'm so late in replying to the post!
 i think that Lupin's patronus is "formless silvery stuff" because he 
isn't an expert at it. He says this himself when Harry asks him to 
teach him.I know that he is a dada teacher but that doesn't mean that 
he is an expert on every defence there is , anyway how many times 
would he have come in to contact with demontors (they appear to stay 
in azcaban all the time).Any way Lupin isn't even facing a  demontor 
when showing harry what to do.He should only produce something like 
clouds when the boggart changes in to the moon,because that's his 
fear , the dementor is Harrys.(Does it ever say what Lupin does to 
the Boggart to defeat it when it changes in to the moon?? and could 
Harry defeat the Boggart/Demontor by imagining it as a clown or 
something funny and joy "creating" like that??)  
> 
> 
> _________________________________________________________
> Do You Yahoo!?
> Get your free @yahoo.com address at http://mail.yahoo.com