Cross-book Foreshadowing (WAS Snape and Harry's first meeting)

[Cindy C.]

No: HPFGUIDX 29079

David wrote:

> > Ever since reading GOF, I have paticularly liked this passage
> > [about Harry's scar hurting him when Quirrel and Snape are 
talking--
> > ed.], because it is one of the few red herrings known to run over
> > more than one book. (IMO, nearly all the red herrings in HP are 
in-
> > book devices - I would love to hear of other multi-book examples.
> 

And Luke wrote:

> So at the moment, there are *no* cross-book, second-time 
> foreshadowing in the books so far that I am aware of, and I 
> personally think many people are too hasty to guess that there will 
> be in future books, given this lack of precedent.  


I hope I am understanding the discussion properly, but I thought we 
had two more instances of cross-book second-time foreshadowing.  I 
think we learn about Scabbers' missing toe in PS/SS, which comes up 
again in PoA.  I also think that we are told repeatedly in PoA and 
GoF that you can't apparate into or out of Hogwarts.  I'd also 
suggest Sirius' motorbike coming up in PS/SS and PoA, but since I 
can't figure out what that might be foreshadowing, I can hardly 
nominate it as a case of cross-book second-time foreshadowing.

Would any of those qualify?

Cindy