McGonagall's Disloyalty

[madaboutsteps at barclays.net]

No: HPFGUIDX 29944



> Klawz wrote:
> "What say ye to the idea of Prof. McGonagall being the
> one who betrays Harry? <snip evidence>"
> 
> >>Then Calypso wrote:
> "Why didn't she stop The Dementor's Kiss on Crouch? Well, I assume 
> that a 
> Dementor is something that not even a witch or wizard wants to get 
> in the way of." 

Then Lucy Wrote:

"I suppose it's a case of what Lupin was saying about a Patronus 
being a very advanced piece of magic - clearly McGonagall's never 
bothered to learn it. Perhaps you only take the trouble to learn the 
spell if you're likely to encounter Dementors, and she didn't think 
that was likely as a law-abiding school teacher! Which also gives the 
interesting side question of just how Lupin came into contact with 
Dementors and needed to learn it?"


This is very true where did he encounter them before because he 
certainly did not back down before them! Maybe we will find out in a 
later novel as J.K Rowling has hinted at his return. Lupin is a very 
mystrious Character or at least I have always thought so, His 
appearence has always struck me as odd, in that Rowling describes him 
as looking "ill and Exhausted" I know that his warewolf status could 
very well be the cause of this but surely not all, maybe he has 
Experienced the Dementors before as Lucy has implied. 
But all this still has not drawn us any closer to a conclusion as to 
whether McGonagall is disloyal and it still remains my opinion that 
she is loyal. The evidence to suggest otherwise is not strong enough 
in my opinion