[HPforGrownups] Lupin Oddities (WAS McGonagall's Disloyalty)

GerRoJen at aol.com GerRoJen at aol.com
Mon Nov 26 02:11:26 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 29997

*MadAboutSteps:
"His [Lupin's] appearence has always struck me as odd, in that Rowling 
describes him as looking "ill and Exhausted" I know that his warewolf status 
could 
very well be the cause of this but surely not all, maybe he has 
Experienced the Dementors before as Lucy has implied."*

You know, I would have to agree with this assessment.  The transformation 
into a werewolf could be a bit exhausting, but to the point where Lupin 
appears to be so "rough around the edges" most of the time?  I have two 
theories as to why this could be, the  first one, I have to thank 
MadAboutSteps for.

*I kind of get the feeling that Lupin is an auror, regardless of his werewolf 
status.  He may come into contact with the Dementors while taking prisoners 
to Azkaban on a regular basis.  He may even work there (which I doubt because 
that would have put him too close to Sirius).  Yet, that brings up another 
question.  Surely there aren't just Dementors running Azkaban, are there?  
Someone has to be there to keep them in line or else they'd be kissing 
everyone in there!  I feel dementors are strictly for guard duty and 
undesirab;e tasks, such as burial duty.  

*In "Fantastic Beasts and Where To Find Them" it says that werewolves are an 
oddity because they always try to seek out human prey.
     "Almost uniquely among fantastic creatures, the werewolf actively seeks 
humans in preferance to any other kind of prey"  (pg. 42)
I am under the assumption that Lupin has never killed another human (or if he 
has, VERY few) while in his transformed state.  Perhaps the lack of these 
dietary preferences accounts for his diminished state. 

Jessie

 




[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]





More information about the HPforGrownups archive