[HPforGrownups] Snape & Dementors (Was: Re: In defense of Snape was: In Defense of McGonagall

[Wy Mar-Ren]

No: HPFGUIDX 30299

I Don't Know, as it seems rather clear to me in my reading of the text, as
what took place in this part of PoA.  Both Snape and McGonagall seem equally
distressed at what had happened, with the dementor, as both had heard Crouch
Jr'.s confession.  It was meant to be interpreted as written.

It is also riveting listening.  I've read PoA but listened to it three
times.
    Philbin
"I shouldn't have said that..."
Subject: [HPforGrownups] Snape & Dementors (Was: Re: In defense of Snape
was: In Defense of McGonagall


>
> It seems to imply that Snape and McGonagall told Fudge together.
>
> 1. Snape did say, 'When *WE* told Mr Fudge' -- a strange choice of
> word given Snape was the only one send to talk to Fudge.  It sounded
> as if he has included McGonagall into the 'we' part.  Very confusing,
> especially from Snape the egomaniac who doesn't seem like the type to
> substitute 'I' with 'we'.  Fudge was on the ground and outside the
> castle when Snape was sent; McGonagall was standing guard outside
> Moody's Office.  Physically impossible for McGonagall to be in two
> places at once.
>