wizards and Muggles
breegenie at yahoo.com
breegenie at yahoo.com
Wed Nov 28 19:19:44 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 30321
Rita wrote:
The wizard folk keep themselves secret from Muggles because THEY
ARE SCARED OF MUGGLES.
Cindy wrote:
I am not sure I would characterize the problem as wizard fear of
Muggles, though. I would say it is more the desire to be left along,
although perhaps different from the way Hagrid sees it. If Muggles
knew about wizards, they might feel threatened and behave
aggressively. These efforts to persecute wizards would be
unsuccessful, of course, but bothersome nonetheless. Indeed, it is
hard to imagine how Muggles could really harm wizards. A wizard
captured by Muggles could simply apparate away, after all.
Cindy
IMHO, wizards avoid Muggles for the same reason anyone who
is "different" avoids the majority--it makes them
<i>uncomfortable</i>. JKR makes this very clear from the beginning of
the series.
Petunia Dursley best expresses this in SS/PS, during her outburst
about her sister. To her parents, Lily (Evans) Potter's magical
abilities made her special. To Petunia, she was a "freak." I'm sure
that most of Muggle society agrees with Petunia, rather than Lily's
parents.
Tolerance is a huge issue in the HP universe. As the wizard community
has enough trouble within itself (Pureblood vs. half-blood vs.
Mudblood) they aren't likely to go searching for more trouble with
the intolerant Muggles.
Bree
another newbie who just "de-lurked"
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive