Dean Thomas

Ebony ebonyink at hotmail.com
Sun Oct 21 13:58:05 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 28026

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., Lea Niiniskorpi <f95lean at d...> wrote:
> Dean Thomas is not mentioned in PS. He is probably sorted before 
Lisa Turpin while Harry is studying the people at the High Table, but 
it is not mentioned in the original edition. I don't know why the 
american editors have added such things, which are quite irrelevant.
> 

*waves hand frantically, having read PS*

Two points of clarification:

1)  Dean is mentioned in PS--just not in that scene.

2)  The details might have been added in the SS edition to:  a) 
appeal to a wider audience, and b) because it's an aspect of Dean's 
character we would have learned about anyway.  The casting of Alicia 
Spinnet shows that JKR's ideas of the characters and our ideas of the 
characters may be diametrically opposed.  But in the end, she's the 
author and she wins.  Simple as that.

--Ebony AKA AngieJ





More information about the HPforGrownups archive