PoA questions

mellienel2 at yahoo.com mellienel2 at yahoo.com
Mon Sep 17 14:08:44 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 26196

> 2. If Lupin was studying the Marauder's Map before running out to 
the 
> shrieking shack, why didn't he see a SECOND Harry Potter and 
Hermione 
> Granger? As they were approaching the shack, the time-travelling 
H&H 
> were on the grounds, in the woods with Buckbeak. We know that the 
> time-travelling self is in that specific time frame because of the 
> Patronus deal -- there are two Harrys by the lake -- and the (and 
> this is an approx. quote) "they heard a last pair of feet run 
across 
> the entrance hall and slam a door" [those feet are Hermione and 
> Harry, time travelling.]. So there should be two Hermiones and two 
> Harrys on the map. If he thought seeing Pettigrew on the map was 
> strange, SURELY seeing two Harry/Hermiones would be stranger. Or 
> maybe he just decided not to say anything about 
it...still...dodgy...


...just noticed this is on the essays, but i can't find the original 
discussion on it. :-)

m.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive