House-Elves [was: In Defense of Hermione]

[dfrankiswork at netscape.net]

No: HPFGUIDX 26747

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., magpie1112 at y... wrote:

> I believe that JKR will have wizards and house elves develop a 
> relationship of equals as the books continue.

Yes, but...
> The house elves will 
> have to overcome their "natural predisposition" to subservience and 
> learn to enjoy their status as beings rather than creatures 
> (developing a sense of self, perhaps?)  

I do not believe that the House-elves have a 'natural predisposition' 
to subservience - they have a culturally-programmed one.  As I 
understand it, this is what Ebony and Pippin were both implying.

I think there is canon evidence that it is not natural or innate.  I 
am referring to the fear which comes over the kitchen elves when 
Hermione starts to challenge them, and with which they regard Dobby.  
This shows that they know that Hermione's and Dobby's way is a real 
possibility for them.  If it was all so natural, they would just 
laugh, and regard Dobby tolerantly as a freak of nature.  As it is 
the abyss has opened in front of them.  

She has them rattled and we can expect earthquakes in due course.

David, who BTW thinks magic and genetics don't mix.