Why the Triwizard Championship?

[sunsetstripbitch77 at yahoo.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 26852

JKR has to make something interesting for each book.  how do you 
think it would look if she wrote a long book with nothing in the 
first 600 pages, and then a battle.  there has to be something more 
going on than just quidditch and exploding cauldrins in potions.  

i also agree with the dramatic death for harry theory.  he is about 
to think that he has won, but instead he dies.  that is what voldie 
and his death eaters would like, isnt it?  

there has to be an interesting battle, or something long and 
iteresting going on in it.  i think i am repeating myself... sorry

i hope i dont sound rude in any way, 
:)



--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Lucy Austin" <lucy at l...> wrote:
> Hello,
> 
> I'd be grateful if someone could solve the problem that's been 
bothering us. Why does Harry have to be entered for the Tournament in 
the first place? Surely if Dumbledore's protections don't work 
against a Portkey on the Quidditch Pitch, they wouldn't work in the 
school either. All the fake Moody has to do is to turn Harry's 
homework book or something into a Portkey and call Harry up to his 
desk to get it. He doesn't care if people see Harry disappear because 
Voldemort will have him by then. If he really wants it to be secret, 
he could just send Harry out of the room to fetch whatever he's 
turned into the Portkey. Can someone make sense of this?
> 
> Lucy
> 
>