Harry, Dumbledore, Fawkes & Flamel / Crouch Jr.

[dicentra63]

No: HPFGUIDX 38014

> cmf_usc wrote:
> >so I was wondering if ya'll had ideas about what types of pets 
>might be
> particularly useful to Harry?
> 
> I haven't done an achive search on this *sorry*, but when I heard 
the third
> book was to be called 'The Order of the Pheonix' it occured to me 
that Harry
> may be bestowed AD's pheonix, Fawkes - maybe after AD's death. No I 
don't
> have any specific cannon for this, but throughout GoF we are drawn 
to the
> fact that AD is looking old and tired, and Fawkes appears to have 
formed an
> attachment to Harry - lands on his lap in AD's office afer the 
third task.
> 
> And just an additional thought, maybe AD, was in fact being kept 
alive by
> the same elixior as Flamel from the philosopher's stone, and he is 
in fact
> running low on his stock pile of the life prolonging substance.
> 
> 
> Also there was a previous discussion about Crouch Jr.
> 
> finwitch wrote:
> 
> >As I read it, I was totally convinced Jr. did *not* do it. That he
> >was just another innocent sent to Azkaban.
> 
> There is a problem with this idea that Crouch Jr. was innocent 
before the
> trial, and it was only his treatment that sent him over to the dark 
side.
> 
> The problem is that the DEs leave a space for the 'faithful' 
servant in the
> circle after LV rebirth (assuming this is refering to Crouch Jr.). 
If Crouch
> Jr. did not go over to the dark side until after LV's downfall then 
there
> would have been no opportunity for the DEs to know there was any 
need for an
> extra space.
> 

--Dicey Elf, in behalf of Karen Peirson, whose software is being 
naughty