[HPforGrownups] Re: "It wuz Snape"

[Ian Malone]

No: HPFGUIDX 42251

>Lost Feyth
>Who is enjoying the It wuz Snape theory, but still likes the idea of it
>being Lupin.

I think one of the main questions of this 3RD MAN theory is that whoever it 
was should have been killed. The main question is; Why didn't Voldemort kill 
the 3RD MAN? Obviously, if the 3rd Man is someone we have alreayd met (or 
will meet in 5 or 6) then they were somehow spared, or got away, or 
survived.

What about this theory, the 3RD MAN was Harry, gone back in time to save his 
parents, but he couldn't do it in time? (Why would he call his mother 
'Lily'? Hmmm.... )


--Ian