Prof. Trelawney deserves credit!

[naama2486]

No: HPFGUIDX 42684

I've been wondering for a while now about Trelawney. All through PoA 
she keeps seeing a Grim, in Harry's teacup, orb etc. right? 
Wrong!

I don't think I'm the first that figured out that she had actually 
saw Sirius as an animagus, but mistakened him for a Grim.
So she saw the sign, but read it wrong. That's more than most can do. 
And think, she was actually the first to find out about him! (she 
just wasn't aware of it...)

Morover, there are those two *true* predictions: the one about the 
return of LV and the one Dumbledore talks about (something like "that 
brings her total of true predictions to two", I don't remember the 
exact quote). I'd say that's a great deal for a fraud. I mean, if 
such predictions could come to anyone, how come Trelawney had them 
*twice*? There must be something about her after all, doesn't it?

So true, she's insanedly fixed on seeing peoples' death, and true, I 
wouldn't let her look at my crystal ball from a mile, but still, she 
deserves *some* credit. 

Just a thought...

 Naama