Voldemort murders in GoF

grey_wolf_c greywolf1 at jazzfree.com
Thu Aug 15 19:43:38 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 42700

Heather Gauen wrote:
> Naama wrote:
> > Well, first of all, it wasn't "one more death" but
> > "one more curse".
> 
> Me:
> Hmmm. Do you have a later edition or a translation of
> a foreign version? I have GoF (American, p. 10) right
> in front of me, and it clearly says "one more death."
> Right before that Wormtail says "if I murder-" and
> Voldemort interrupts with "the Ministry need never
> know anyone else died." (paraphrasing here, sorry)
> Then, on page 12, Volemort continues musing, "One more
> murder..." So what I have is Voldemort *repeatedly*
> saying that he is going to kill someone else.

OK, I've got a translated edition of GoF, so my copy is as valid as 
yours in principle (hey, at least in my translated versions all titles 
are correct ;-p ). In my version there is no future death. Peter says 
that "And, if we continue, if I throw the curse". Voldemort, in the 
same line, first speaks of "One less obstacle", which I admit could 
mean almost *anything*, but then specifies "One more curse" (all quotes 
are Sp. Ed. GoF ch. 1, Liberal translation).

Since I don't think Naama has them in my language, that's two against 
one by now, although I'll be the first to admit that the only one that 
really counts is the original, British text. Any brits out there that 
care give us the original text?

Hope that helps,

Grey Wolf






More information about the HPforGrownups archive