Voldemort murders in GoF
alhewison
Ali at zymurgy.org
Thu Aug 15 20:59:22 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 42711
Grey Wolf responding to the question about
Voldemort's "murders/deaths" to be committed in GoF wrote:
>>> Since I don't think Naama has them in my language, that's two
against one by now, although I'll be the first to admit that the
only one that really counts is the original, British text. Any brits
out there that care give us the original text?>>>
GoF 1st edition (& 4th edition?) UK p 15, Wormtail says:
"if I CURSE"
Voldemort says:- "one more obstacle removed"
p16: "One more curse...my faithful servant at Hogwarts"
It is still unclear why Scholastic made the changes to the text.
Perhaps it was in response to Frank Bryce's musings about
Voldemort: "And he was planning more murders-this boy, Harry Potter,
whoever he was - was in danger...". From my perspective whilst
Voldemort does not value life, there is no specific mention of death,
so why does Bryce think that there is. He does understand the grave
predicament that Harry is facing, but why the plural "more murders".
I think that this section of text is "messy" whether you read the UK
or US editions. The UK edition with mention of curse and obstacle
proves itself to be canonically correct as Moody is imperioed, but
for me at any rate Frank Bryce is reading more into Voldemort's
speech than I can - but then again I have the advantage of being able
to continually re-read it, and am not in a life-threatening situation!
Ali
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive