I'm not sure this is the right forum, but... about the mysteries FAQ
marephraim
htfulcher at comcast.net
Sun Aug 18 19:00:59 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 42887
The website "http://www.i2k.com/~svderark/lexicon/faq/index.html"
has a FAQ. (i'm assuming this group is related. if not forgive me.)
There are several 'mysteries' listed there that seem (to me, at
least) not to be so mysterious. I'm listing some possible answers
below. Some me may be more plausible than others, but what do you
think?
"How does Hagrid "fly" to the Hut on the Sea? On a broomstick? If
so, where is it the next morning? Superman style?"
Maybe Dumbledore apparated him (a kind of flying?)
"Hagrid and Harry take the boat that the Dursleys used to get to the
Hut on the Sea in Chapter 3 of SS. How then do the Dursleys get to
land?"
With some difficulty. They would have to wait for the man who rented
it to them to show up, etc..
"How can Sirius Black apparently openly own his flying motorcycle
and yet Mr. Weasley's flying Ford Anglia is illegal? "
When was the law passed? There is a comment in CoS to the effect
that Mr Weasley himself wrote the law in question.
"What was the size of this motorcycle? It was described as a giant
motorcycle at one point, but if so, how did Sirius ride it? If it
wasn't giant-sized, how would Hagrid have ridden it? "
A magic motorcycle might change size to accomodate the driver.
"Hermione indicates on the Hogwarts Express that she has already
tried a few simple spells for practice. Why didn't she get a
letter
from the Ministry of Magic as Harry did in CoS? "
Perhaps the rule only applies after one has enrolled in the school.
"How does Dobby (then the Malfoys' house elf) visit Harry in the
hospital wing after the Quidditch match? "
This one has to be a real error. Consider when Dobby visits Harry in
the Hospital Wing. There is a snap! and he's gone....
In SS, Harry's glasses are supposedly "taped" together in
the middle
because they'd been broken by Dudley so frequently. In CoS, Harry
breaks his glasses (which appear to be whole) when he lands in
Knockturn Alley. Were his glasses repaired at some point during SS
By Hermione after the yellow scabbers charm fails (at least in the
movie this is so, although I don't find it in the UK version of PS).
"Why would Lupin not transform when the boggart turns into the moon?
If it's because it's not really the moon, then why does Harry hear
his parents' dying moments and faint when the boggart turns into a
dementor? "
Trauma? Boggart attempts to frighten you. Lupin would be frightened
of the full moon but not physically transforemed by it. Harry, on
the other hand, because he's been affected by Voldemort's attack,
mentally 'relives' an experience he would not otherwise remember.
"If it's available in bottles, why was Lupin so surprised and
suspicious when Harry says Ron and Hermione brought him some back
(explaining why he'd tasted it before)? "
Believing that Harry had not had an opportunity to visit the village
he thought it would be a new experience. Harry's instant and
delighted recognition would make him suspicious. On the other hand,
Rowling has a knack for describing an event or reaction according to
how Harry and his compatriots perceive it. Thus Lupin's "reaction"
to Harry's recognition of the Butterbeer could be no more than a
description of Harry's sense of guilt and fear of discovery for his
unauthorised trip into town.
I haven't finished my 3rd reading of PoA and GoF, so I have no
comments on the remainder of FAQs.
Sorry if this duplicates other msgs; it just struck me as probable
answers to these particular questions.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive