Some mistakes in book1???

ats_fhc3 the.gremlin at verizon.net
Fri Dec 6 06:08:24 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 47828

Gail B. wrote:
"Can I tell you what bugs me about this whole scenario?  When Snape 
got wounded, why didn't he go to the infirmary and get himself fixed 
up? Instead, he limps around days after the attack.  Why does he 
have Filch change the bandages instead of Madame Pomfrey?  Seems 
really strange."

What would he have told her? "Oh, one of my slimy things in a jar 
bit me." Course, the limping was a little obvious. You would have 
thought another teacher would notice. And Filch and Snape seem to 
have some sort of special rapport going on...oh, no. Well, it's been 
done.

Long story short, he didn't have Madam Pomfrey fix him up because he 
didn't want her to know. Though someone speculated awhile ago (a 
long long while ago) that he didn't like to be seen as weak, so 
there's another reason. With Filch, it's okay...for some odd reason. 
Well, Filch wouldn't try to put pajamas on Snape and tuck him into 
bed. Madam Pomfrey would fret and tut and what-not, and generally 
make Snape feel like a child, which I'm sure he doesn't want to feel 
like (even though he ACTS like one sometime...love him, but he needs 
to GROW UP).

-Acire, who isn't sure wether she should call her college 
instructors 'professor' or 'teacher'. 'Professor' is like HP, 
and 'teacher' is like high school. 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive