Theory on why harry had to go home (end book 4)

BoBaFeTT bobafett at harbornet.com
Wed Dec 11 20:53:27 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 48160


Why?
Why Did Dubledore Insist Harry 
Go Back Home To The Dursley's?

Well, aside from the basic fact he's protected there, it seemed to me there was more than that in Dumbledore's comment when in GoF he told Mrs. Weasley that Harry must go back to the Dursley's, at least at first.

It makes me think more about what exactly the situation is there and then like before something  blinked in the  minuscule thing I call my mind.

What if they reveal info to him? Now, don't get ahead of me here I'm not thinking about info on his family but more to the fact why they are so cruel to him.

What if the Dursleys aren't muggles at all; what if the reason they are so mean to Harry is because HE and NOT their little Duddy is a warlock! What if Mr. and Mrs. Dursley are wizards and Dudley was born a Muggle.

This would be a plausible explanation why they abused Harry all these years, The jealousy of Harry being a wizard and not Dudley could have driven them to this.

thnx

BoBaFeTT 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]






More information about the HPforGrownups archive