[HPforGrownups] Theory on the Death in book 5?

[Angela Evans]

No: HPFGUIDX 48171

 
 BoBaFeTT <bobafett at harbornet.com> wrote:

Here it states, and i quote, 
"McDonald, Natalie 
Gryffindor, 94-01 

Natalie's name comes from a Canadian girl who was very sick. She loved the Harry Potter books and contacted JKR. The author wrote her and told her her some of the secrets of the books to come, but Natalie 
had died by the time the letter arrived. Natalie's mother responded and she and JKR have since become friends. Jo put Natalie in GF, sorted into Gryffindor, as a tribute. 


So I concluded that considering both these sorces reliable and the facts displayed acurat i would say that Natlie McDonald would be a "FAN" and her Death would be "Horrible to write". >



ME: i find this HIGHLY unlikely for two reasons

1) these plot line of all seven books has been basically planned out for years.  the addition of the name Natalie MacDonald while writing GoF, does not mean the addition of a character and a related plot line that would completely change everything she had worked out

2) i think it was a wonderful tribute.  but the thought of killing off this deceased little girl's namesake, is a little sick frankly

are you being serious? or am i missing the joke?  i don't mean that as an insult, just sometimes i can be a bit clueless.

 

ANGELA







---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail Plus - Powerful. Affordable. Sign up now

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]