Question about Boggarts

Tammy Bianchi Resqgal911 at msn.com
Fri Dec 13 04:40:00 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 48252

>sherry wrote:
>My question, then, is this:  If Harry is affected as though the Boggart
were a
>real Dementor, why isn't Lupin affected as though the Boggart were the real
>moon?
>

>Then illyana wrote:
>Hmmm... that's a good question. I'm thinking that maybe, since the
>Boggart!Dementor was full-size, it had the full effects of a normal
>Dementor. Lupin's Boggart!moon was so much smaller in comparison to
>the actual moon, so maybe that's why it didn't have the
>werewolf-transforming effects on him that the actual moon does.

Me:

Good point illyanna.  I also think that Lupin was probably taking his potion
at that point of the book so the moon shouldn't have affected him.  Does
anyone have information regarding the abilities of boggarts?  If a
dementor!boggart can affect someone the same as a real dementor, can it give
The Kiss?

Tammy





More information about the HPforGrownups archive