Hermione's wand and related question.
jodel at aol.com
jodel at aol.com
Sat Dec 21 21:54:43 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 48665
Lisa, (Newcastle,Australia) Asks;
>>Does anyone have any information regarding the properties of Hermione's
wand?
<snip>
2. Despite Ollivander's assertion, "You'd never get such good results with
another Wizard's wand",(P.S.,64), first year Hermione was able to flawlessly
perform the alohomora charm with Harry's wand. A wand fine-tuned to Harry
and, by the nature of their connection, to Voldemort.<<
When did this happen? I don't recall Hermione performing any spells with
*Harry's* wand. (Although if it was during the labrynth sequence, that was
the end of the year, by which time most students would have been able to get
*some* results from somebody else's wand. And Hermione might be3 expected to
be better than average at it -- she was at everything else.)
As to Hermione's wand, we have been told *nothing* of it to date. (It's
mostly the boys who go about bragging about their wands, after all.) I
wouldn't be at all surprised to learn that her wand has a phoenix feather
core. (She IS good at Transfiguration, and phoenix feather seems to be the
most excellent conductor for "change" magic -- as unicorn hair is for "charm"
magic. We still don't know what dragon heartstring's specialty is.) But for
symetry one might rather expect her to carry dragon heartstring. (We already
know that Harry's is phoenix feather and Ron's is unicorn hair.)
Somewhere back in the archives there was a nice little discussion of the
symbolism attached to dfferent trees which you might find interesting. I
don't know whether the wand in question that set it off was Snapes or
Hermione's but it might have been either.
For the record, we don't know the components of Dumbledore's wand either. Or
of any of the teachers', except Hagrid's original one. (Oak and dragon
heartstring, 16 inches.)
-JOdel (who agrees that the most likely scenareo for a "betrayal" from
Hermione is for her to pass information to the wrong party out of
misjudgement of character/motives.)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive