Was Barty!Moody's plans for Harry - DADA teachers--Is Fleur as DADA Teacher
The Real Makarni <pat_mahony@hotmail.com>
pat_mahony at hotmail.com
Mon Dec 23 10:37:16 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 48712
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, alexpie at a... wrote:
> Fleur seems to me enormously unskilled in tackling the Dark
Arts. She never
> bested the other TriWizard candidates and, indeed, when it
meant most to her,
> couldn't manage a simple spell of any kind to save Gabrielle.
What in the
> world could she teach Hogwarts students, except what not to
do?
> Mind you, I think canon has shown that she's quite a nice girl,
once she
> overcame her shyness/haughtiness (either/both?), but a
teacher? I think not!
I agree with you wholeheartedly that Fleur is unlikely to be a
DADA teacher, mainly because I belive that Dumbledore is going
to put someone from the "old crowd" in that position.
However, Fleur isn't totally incompetent. I TBAYed a pair of
theories *ages* ago, examining other possibile subject areas for
her to teach.
Look at the first task with the dragons- Fleur was able to use a
charm that put the dragon to sleep. She was able to control the
dragon the best out of the four (at least in my opinion), and this
means she could be adept at CoMC.
This also shows that she is adept at charms- not only is she
able to charm the dragon, she uses the bubble-head charm
(and still gets half points in doing so), and we don't know how
she performed in the final task. Add into that mix her natural
Veela "charm", and you have yourselves a potential Charms
professor. Of course, that would necessitate the fall of Prof.
Flitwick. . .
See ya
Roo
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive