More LOLLIPOPS, Timeline, WL3

[anavenc]

No: HPFGUIDX 34870

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "judyserenity" <judyshapiro at e...> wrote:
(on to EWW to be trEWW)
 
> First of all, thank you Cindy for realizing that I was the first to 
> propose this theory, as well as calling it creative and logical!  
> However, in my theory, Voldemort just *thinks* Snape would be 
willing 
> to stoop to love potions or Imperio to get Lily to fall in love with 
> him.  In my theory, Snape is actually appalled by the whole idea.


Oops, Judy. I honestly thought it was Pippin's theory.  My sincere 
apologies!  *blushes*
Anyhow I still think that this theory is too *ahem* adult.  Remember 
JKR's musing on Hermione's going and getting pregnant at the age of 
fourteen: it wouldn't work in this kind of story. For me,the same is 
true about Lily's-imperius-induced-love-as-a-reward-for-faithful-DEs 
idea. 

An ingenious theory, though!


Ana.