Mountains=the "new place" ?

reepicheepuk reepicheepuk at yahoo.co.uk
Thu Feb 28 09:18:15 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 35852

abced99420 wrote:

> I've lately been attempting to plot out what I think will happen in 
> the whole of book 5, to stave off despair of it will actually ever 
be 
> published. Anyway, I am of the opinion that Hagrid will be the one 
> to die, and I figure that if JKR is going to kill off one of her 
> personal favorite characters, she will most likely give him some 
> major "screen time" first. What better way to do that than give 
> Hagrid his own major subplot with the giants, in the mountains? 
> What I haven't figured out yet is a plausible time and reason for 
> Harry to go to the mountains with him? Does anyone have any 
> ideas about this? I think that "giant land" would be a very 
> interesting place to see!

Well, even IF we take for granted SOMEONE's going to die, I don't see 
why you assume it's going to be Hagrid. You would need to be more 
specific about that. (Of course, I don't like the idea of him dying, 
that's obvious.) If GoF is anything to go on, I feel it more likely 
that some minor character is going to be the victim, anyway. After 
all, Cedric, on second thoughts, seems to have been invented for the 
only pupose to get killed off. Anyway, if it was book 7 we're talking 
about, it would seem more likely that some of the major characters 
are in for it, but definitely not book 5.
However, I fully agree with you that "Giant Land" would be an 
interesting place to see. 

Greetings,

reepicheep






More information about the HPforGrownups archive