Some more thoughts about Lily, Remus, Sirius

[finwitch]

No: HPFGUIDX 33853

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., Katze <jdumas at k...> wrote:



> 
> My husband has a much closer groups of friends, and they are very 
much
> the same way. They accepted me with open arms (I moved out here...so 
I
> knew and didn't know anyone). So I find it unusual to pain Lily as 
the
> bad person who tried to steal James away. 
> 
> My impression is that Lily and James were both liked at Hogwarts, 
and
> Sirius and Remus (not sure about Peter...cause he just follows) 
accepted
> her as another friend. 

They accepted her, yes. But, she wasn't in doing the map...

> They also only seem to speak 
bout
> James when asked...no questions have been asked about Lily, which 
seems
> to be the reason they don't speak about her.

Pretty much so. At least when Harry's around. How do they know how 
much Harry's ready or willing to hear? They don't unless Harry asks. 
Sirius... well, it seems as if Sirius and James grew up together and 
met Remus and Peter at school.