SHIP: Some R/H questions
ladjables
ladjables at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 25 19:50:31 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 34064
To all R/H, H/H shippers,
I've been browsing through the SHIP posts, and correct me if I'm
wrong, but there seems to be an underlying notion that Ron doesn't
deserve Hermione(meant facetiously?), but it has me flummoxed.
I've never been a shipper really, but as of Goblet of Fire, I thought
JKR established some sort of chemistry between the Ron and Hermione,
if that's what you can call what 14 year olds experience. I,(quite
arrogantly) never imagined that other fans hoped Harry and Hermione
might discover feelings for each other. It doesn't bother me if I
never saw a H/H coming, but the idea that Ron and Hermione cannot
work because he is below her standards, or isn't worthy of her, does.
Have you ever noticed couples who have been together for ever, and
for the life of you, you can't imagine WHY? There you are, wondering
and pondering, railing and wailing that they will never last, and yet
there they are, blissfully proving you wrong. Even if theirs is a
relationship that relishes warfare, this doesn't mean it's
unsuccessful. I know of a husband and wife, polar opposites, who
have fought every day of their now 30 year marriage. But they're
happy. Would R and H theoretically not work out because they fight
all the time? Is that a bad thing? Or is that just the way they
communicate?
I have no lofty theory for why H/H belong together, except I believe
Ron would be as good for Hermione as she would be for him. It
doesn't matter if he's Harry's sidekick, or he exhibits extreme
jealousy while Harry is capable of such admirable strength of
character (I'm not saying these are anyone's reasons). I think
comparing Harry and Ron is deceptive. In my eyes they're equal even
if they're not alike. Either of them would make good, albeit
different boyfriends.
Both Hermione and Harry depend on Ron. He anchors the trio very
well, since H and H are struggling to find their place in the
wizarding world. It's true he's trying to carve out a niche for
himself as the 6th Weasley boy, but this isn't comparable to Harry
and Hermione, who are muggle-raised. He has a certain level of
security they don't have. What I think is very significant about Ron
and Hermione's relationship however is that Ron is the only person
who will take Hermione down a peg. (I will probably get flamed for
this).
I'm not saying Hermione should become a floozy because she's too
brilliant, but in some ways I think her obsession with schoolwork is
to compensate for her insecurity about other facets of her
character. Ron sees right through her when she's being intolerably
know-it-all, or gets her to relax when she's hyperventilating, I
think there's evidence in the canon, especially when they're yelling
at each other over homework. I believe this why Ron is very good for
Hermione. And what does this have to do with them being a couple?
Probably nothing, but that's my reasoning. Hermione may challenge
Ron to become more ambitious, but Ron may challenge Hermione to let
her hair down, I know she can do this on her own, but his telling her
has an impact as well.
What I really want to say is, don't underrate Ron's character because
he isn't as clever as Hermione, or not a Harry Potter; he has his
merits too. I don't think he has to become a great chess champion or
have some other secret talent(even though that would be fine too) to
be worthy of either the trio or Hermione; I happen to like him the
way he is. And I really don't think any of those things matter when
it comes to relationships. They may enhance them, but they don't
bolster them. Good lord, I'm discussing the love lives of fictitious
14 year olds, time to go. Forgive the ramble, especially if I've
repeated last year's theories, and please feel free to unspool this
mess.
Ama
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive