Can Muggles do Magic?
uncmark
uncmark at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 18 04:31:53 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 41372
Help me settle an argument between me and my niece. Could a Muggle
like Dudley raid Harry's trunk and cause havoc? Dudley falls through
a loophole of the MoM being a family member and The trunk has no
magic locks as far as I know. (Ginny broke into it to find Riddle's
diary in CofS)
My niece and I agree that wands wouldn't work for a Muggle, but she
thinks that nothing else would either. I played devil's advocate
bringing upArthur Weasley's Muggle Protection work. In CofS Ch. 3
Arthur told Harry about an enchanted tea set and biting kettle that
was accidentally bought by Muggles.
Now if a Teaset would work for Muggles, wouldn't an invisibility
cloak? Could Dudley fly a broom? Agreed Dudley's stupid, but could
you picture him finding Harry's potion book and trying to brew
something to make him lose weight?
Opinions?
Uncmark
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive