Can Muggles do Magic? In the cases you mentined, yes.
peppermintfatty
peppermintfatty at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 18 19:22:09 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 41398
>
> Now if a Teaset would work for Muggles, wouldn't an invisibility
> cloak? Could Dudley fly a broom? Agreed Dudley's stupid, but could
> you picture him finding Harry's potion book and trying to brew
> something to make him lose weight?
For the most part I would have to agree with you. The cloak is a
physical object constructed with it's own magical properties. There
is no evidence that the wizard has anything to do with it functioning
correctly. While I cannot think of the exact instances right now, I
believe that the cloak has been used to cover up inanimate objects
before. It would seem to me that it would have the same properties on
whatever it covered. In the case of a broom, as can be found
in "Quidditch through the Ages", the reason magical folk started
using them was that they were inexpensive and would not raise muggle
eyebrows. They also mention that those who were skilled broom makers
traded their services with those skilled in other areas. This leads
me to believe that a wizard broom, at least in the beginning, is
nothing more than a muggle broom, with a charm on it. We have seen
cases as with Harry's Nimbus 2000, where it flew off and hit the
whomping willow, that a broom can fly without a wizard. In this case
all of these facts lead me to believe that a muggle could fly a
broomstick the same as they could the ford Anglia, with the
difference being that they probably would not be very skilled at it.
As for the potions, I agree there again. Potions nowhere in cannon
have been shown to be magical per se...as with no incantations
or "fancy wand waving"...they are concoctions made up of various
objects, some of which are magical (i.e.: Unicorn Hair). If Dudley
were to raid Harry's trunk and found a book of potions, as well as
some of Harry's potions class supplies, I think he theoretically
COULD produce some havoc causing potions. The only problems would be
if things were labeled. If not, then Dudley, being a great git, would
have no idea what was what. So I agree with you in theory, as neither
broomsticks, the cloak, or potions seem to have anything to do with
the internal magical properties of wizards, but instead the magical
properties of the ingredients in potions, or the magical properties
imputed by the wizards to the objects in question in regards to the
broomstick and the cloak.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive