wizard education
bluesqueak
pipdowns at etchells0.demon.co.uk
Sun Jul 21 08:00:30 UTC 2002
No: HPFGUIDX 41491
> Pip!Squeak wrote:
>
> <<JKR has invented the Potterverse. It is her world, and she's
> still creating it. If she says there are no other wizarding schools
> in Great Britain, then there-are-no-other-wizarding schools. Full
stop.>>
>
Catlady replied:
> JKR Interviews: Hogwarts is the only wizarding school for UK and it
> has 1000 students.
>
> Books: the references to other schools cited by Elkins and the
> depiction of approximately 280 students at Hogwarts Castle.
>
> Way to make all this evidence be true at the same time: Hogwarts
> has more than one campus. The original campus, the Castle, has
> circa 280 students and is called "Hogwarts" for short, while the
> other campus(es) are named Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and
> Wizardry at (e.g.) Woodcroft and called e.g. "Woodcroft", just as
> the University of California campus at Berkeley is nicknamed "Cal",
> while the one in Los Angeles is "UCLA".
>
One problem I have with the 'campus' theory is that my experience of
English schools was that a school on a different campus, with a
different name is errr..... a different school.
There are some 'multi-campus' colleges and universities, yes, so I
suppose 'more than one campus' is possible for Hogwarts; my other,
more serious problem is that Harry's letter only refers to his being
admitted to the 'Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry', whereas
multi-campus colleges tend to a) be very firm about WHICH campus you
report to and b) refer to the other campuses once in a while.
My personal preference is the 'normal times' theory, which I've seen
referred to on the list. Hogwarts has 1000 or so students *in normal
times*. Harry's year and the years immediately above and below him
are not normal - they were affected by the fact that the WW by and
large, simply didn't want to risk having children during the
Voldemort wars; and also by the fact that a large number of people
died, so the number of people available to *have* children also
dropped.
This did happen in the UK during the Second World War - the birth
rate dropped like a stone during the War, then rocketed immediately
after. It is a complete pain for the education system, as there is
now a well known pattern (hits every 20 years or so) of class sizes
dropping (so teaching staff are cut) followed a few years later by a
massive increase in class sizes as the children/grandchildren/great-
grandchildren of the wartime drop/post war bulge generations hit the
school system.
Pip
Squeak!
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive