What did Voldemort do that was so great?

mrflynn6 mrflynn6 at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 25 12:51:46 UTC 2002


No: HPFGUIDX 41694

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "cathubodva_raven" <wedgeaholic at i...> 
wrote:
> Jenny from Ravenclaw wrote:
> 
> >I also wanted to add a comment about using "Voldemort did great 
> >things" as an example of what Draco may turn out to be.  When 
> >Ollivander made that comment, just like Harry, I became 
> >uncomfortable.  I wondered what JKR meant by that.  I would never, 
> >ever think to use the word 'great' in relation to Voldemort.  He's 
> >not great.  He may be smart, he may be resourceful, he may be a 
> >powerful leader, but he ain't great.  He's evil.  I would say the 
> >same for Hitler.  There wasn't a great bone in that man's body, no 
> >matter what brilliant, horrifying and devastatingly successful 
plan 
> >he had at the time.  
> 

> 
> Cathubodva.


-----------------------------

If you use the simplistic definition of a great leader as one that 
gets people to follow him/her and do what he/she wants, then 
Voldermort was a great leader (as was Hitler).  Don't confuse great 
with being an ethical leader or good person.  One can be a great 
leader and be a rotten person.  Voldermort had many, many followers 
that were all ready and willing.


Gretchen





More information about the HPforGrownups archive